As the Blue Jackets quietly went into the night against the Flyers on Saturday, frustration within the 5th Line reached a new level. The team on the ice continues to disappoint, and the fanbase has reached its boiling point. So, we asked for your opinions on how to fix the whole thing. Today, we'll take a look at some of the responses we got.
I'll preface this by mentioning that I'm definitely no expert. I'm just a fan, like everyone in the responses. But, I have been around hockey teams my entire life, from playing, watching, scouting, and working in the media.
So, while I don't consider myself an expert, I do believe I have a feel for what it takes to build a hockey team. At the moment, I'm of the opinion that the Blue Jackets are nowhere close. It's not all doom and gloom, but if they don't right this ship soon (last week would have been a good time to start), I think darker days lie ahead. Maybe the darkest we have seen, which says a lot about how I feel about things right now.
That's the sentiment we got in almost every response on X. Frankly, this isn't good enough, and it's time for someone to do something about it. Maybe that starts with a grassroots effort, such as the fanbase voicing their discontent. We're here to give you that platform.
The 5th Line is fed up.
The best way to start this thing off: lets just post the comments from the fans who have simply had enough. I think these responses are perfectly reasonable, considering the state of this franchise.
I’m not sure how you fix something when you have ownership that cares more about their golf course than their pro sports team.
— Justin Needham (@jneedham24) November 15, 2026
Do not sign on for season tickets for next year. Only buy on secondary markets from individual ticket sellers. Show up with visiting teams gear and enjoy watching a winning team. Fill the stadium with visiting team fans and limit the money to the org, and things will change.
— ∵doogan∴ (@doogan69) November 15, 2026
Its a joke. Almost every decision in thr off-season has backfired. We should have blown it up last year but we went on an insane run and tried to keep it together.
— MACHOGOSAVAGE Pro Wrestler Vtuber (@MachoGoSavage) November 15, 2026
Ownership does not care so why should we? People dont even know this team exists its so bad. Its pathetic
Well it do any good will the #CBJ see this? And will the follow what we say
— Thomas Duffield (@ThomasDufft4) November 16, 2026
To answer the question above, I doubt it will do us any good. But, I do know that these responses are being read by decision makers within the organization. You can all trust us on that one, it has been made clear to us recently.
Fire 'em all out of the cannon.
Easily the most popular response to this question: fire everybody. Some people added the caveat of a full rebuild. Others called out ownership (more on that later). There were a ton of responses with this ideology, far too many to post here. So, we'll just share a few:
Sell the team and fire EVERYBODY. Do not let anybody currently in the organization continue. New faces are needed at every level in the organization.
— James F. (@james_hockey61) November 15, 2026
1- Fire DW. Let a group braintrust run things until a competent, forward-thinking leader can be identified.
— Jonathan Barnes 🍕 (@osubluejacket) November 15, 2026
2- Have all players over 30 make trade lists & start shopping them. Cut bait, cut salary, get picks/prospects.
3- Keep coaches through EOY. Reset that in the offseason.
Fire DW and try to properly rebuild around Fantilli, Johnson, Sillinger, and Maytechuk. All others you field offers on
— Travis (@Trav614) November 15, 2026
Fire Waddell. Hire someone fresh. Make Coyle captain. Be bad for a couple years. Load up on prospects. prioritize development. Rebrand to the cannon jerseys. Our current young core is young enough to be a part of the solution on the other side of a rebuild if we start soon.
— MittsOfMarinaraCBJ (@MittsOfMarinara) November 15, 2026
Sadly rebuild! Fire the GM and the head coach go as well. Whatever the game plan is isn’t working. Next, have to sell a few of your valued assets. Can’t afford to waste their selling potential being bottom of the league. Short term pain for long term gain.
— Wheeling Lake Erie (@WheelingE64110) November 15, 2026
Pretty hard to disagree with any of these comments, even the ones I wasn't able to share. I do think it's time for this organization to at least consider nuking the whole thing and starting over. Again. If the plan is to do that, then I definitely agree that Don Waddell is not the guy for the job.
Ownership into question again.
Finally, lets talk about ownership. If nobody in the organization is doing their part, you have an organizational problem. That falls onto the shoulders of the people with the greatest vested (note: invested) interest in the team. We're talking to you, McConnell family.
Very simple. Not easy, but the solution is not complex (hence simple). Hands-off leadership works when things are going well. When they are not, corrective action has to be taken. It starts with the top. This whole organization has become complacent with being mediocre. So, you…
— Michael Nef 🇺🇸🇨🇭 (@michaelnef44) November 15, 2026
Ownership needs to take a commitment to excellence to heart and show that is what is expected from everyone in the organization. Absent ownership, mail in front office, it just metastasizes into a culture of good enough.
— HRH Sean I of Nowhere Particular (@SeanOfNowhere) November 16, 2026
Look at any successful professional franchise and it all starts with ownership. Which is unfortunately something that cannot be fired. This whole org needs cleansed. They don’t draft well, develop well, or coach well.
— Chris (@dadopher75) November 15, 2026
Couldn't have said any of this better myself. I want to take a moment and thank everyone for taking their time to give us feedback. As I mentioned before, I know there are people within the organization who are seeing this, and they do care. Whether or not it changes anything, will have to wait to be seen.
The fact of the matter: nobody wants to see this team succeed more than the 5th Line does, so I hope they take these comments to heart. We will share our own thoughts on how we think they might be able to turn this thing around, a little bit later today.
