Skip to main content

Can the mess the Blue Jackets are in even be cleaned up at this point?

Don Waddell has dug the Blue Jackets in pretty deep. Can they climb out of this pit, or are we destined for another long rebuild in Columbus?
ByCurtis Deem
Nov 12, 2026; Columbus, Ohio, USA;  Columbus Blue Jackets left wing Matthew Knies (89) celebrates his goal against the Tampa Bay Lightning during the first period at Nationwide Arena.  Mandatory Credit: Russell LaBounty-Imagn Images
Nov 12, 2026; Columbus, Ohio, USA; Columbus Blue Jackets left wing Matthew Knies (89) celebrates his goal against the Tampa Bay Lightning during the first period at Nationwide Arena. Mandatory Credit: Russell LaBounty-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
3 of 3

Step 2: adapt to the modern NHL.

This one is really quite simple, and we laid it all out last week. The Blue Jackets are operating like a team stuck in the late-90s/early 2000s era. They're building a team to play "dead puck" hockey, and while it may be working for some teams...it ain't working here.

I'm not sure if it's the wrong mix of players, poor coaching, or all of the above. But this team is boring, slow, and devoid of skill outside of a small handful of players.

On any given night, one line seems to be generating offense. Can we even say they have had a single night where two or more lines have been buzzing around this season? I can't recall any. Most nights, we're stuck with a frustrating dump and chase system that just gives the other team the puck. That's not how you play offense in the modern NHL.

If Waddell is capable of building this back up: great, keep him on board. I'm skeptical. If he cannot, find a GM that can use modern analytics or scouting methods to identify talent, and bring that person aboard. Keep Don as a consultant, if you want, but I would take the decision making out of his hands at this point in time. He's had three years, and things look to be heading in a very dark direction.

I don't want to see any more band-aid fixes that rob this team of longer-term talent. Especially not in favor of another slow two-way veteran with an ugly contract.

Step 3: cut out the cancer.

This is the elephant in the room that nobody wants to talk about: there is a lot of talent on this roster. More than enough to win hockey games. At least, more than the 2 regulation wins they have pieced together so far this year.

If one or two guys are having a down year, you shake it off and move on. If the entire team is having a down year, there is something significantly wrong.

It's obvious from the outside looking in: something stinks here. Again, I don't know if it's coaching, players, management, or some combination of all of the above. Whatever is causing this team to not play like a team needs to go.

After you do that, spend the rest of this year identifying the core pieces you want to keep around for the long-term, and blow it all up. Anybody that doesn't want to be here through another rebuild can hit the road. Get as much for them as you can. Yard sale time.

Some of the veterans will want to stay, and that's fine. Notably, the ones with trade protection in their contracts. You will need some of those guys around, even when the team is down in the dumps. But you have to move on from the rest (sorry Zach), and build this thing up right this time.

It might take another 3, or maybe even 5 years, but lets be honest with each other here: is this team more than a wild card contender at this point? At their absolute very peak, are they competing for anything more than that?

I don't think so.

And, that window is only going to be open for 2 or 3 years anyway, with the way this thing has been managed. It's time for this organization to realize that now, before their GM makes any more desperate moves to try to salvage his job. Moves similar to the ones that have torn apart anything meaningful we gained from starting the rebuild in the first place.

Once that happens, if rebuilt correctly, this team could eventually turn into what it was advertised to be this year: a contender. Until then, well, I hope you guys are happy with having less than sell-out crowds at Nationwide Arena. Because nobody wants to pay money to see this team right now.

Add us as a preferred source on Google