Step 1: we want to hear from ownership.
We will forever be grateful for John H McConnell and his efforts to bring an NHL franchise to the city of Columbus. Without him, we would not be here today. He was a wonderful ambassador and a great owner, even if the on-ice results fell short. The team never made the playoffs until after his passing, which is honestly a shame.
With that said, it's time to talk about the state of affairs since he passed. From an ownership perspective, it's been nothing but crickets. While I get that this group prefers to keep a hands off approach; at some point in time, they need to step up and say enough is enough. My personal opinion is that we are at that point.
The Blue Jackets entered a rebuild all the way back in 2021, by trading away as many meaningful core pieces as they could, in exchange for draft picks and other futures. It's not uncommon for teams to burn through their GM when they decide to take this route, because let's be honest: losing sucks.
And lose they did. The Jackets were in shambles from the 2020-21 season, all the way up until 2024-25. They went through four head coaches in this span, with the last hire only lasting around 18 months before being canned.
Of course, GM Jarmo Kekalainen did lose his job, and he was replaced by one of the league's most experienced front office people, Don Waddell. The team had a bit of a bump the last two years, coming dangerously close to a playoff spot. But they have not been able to take another step since. This year, the seem to be taking several steps back.
This is precisely where I think ownership needs to ask some hard questions, or at least explain the situation better to this fanbase. What are the expectations for this team? What are the expectations for Don Waddell?
One of the knocks on Kekalainen was his heavy-handed approach to things. He was a terrific evaluator of talent, but he was known for grinding guys into submission come contract time; as well as hiring tough head coaches.
As a result, the organization went in the complete opposite direction in hiring Waddell. He's known for having a much softer touch, good at keeping players in town and building cohesive teams from the top down.
So, why is it that the only players he's acquired have been aging veteran middle-six forwards and bottom-four defensemen? And, if his job was to retain the talent that this organization bottomed out to acquire: why wasn't he able to convince Kirill Marchenko to sign long-term?
I would love to see ownership answer these questions. Not Waddell himself, or anyone else working for the McConnells. I want to see a real decision maker standing at the podium. Send a message to your fanbase-check that, your customers-that you will demand greater accountability from the top down and do your best to provide us with a better product.
We're just getting started. Lets talk about the next steps on another slide.
