Three Active Former Blue Jackets Who Would be Perfect for this Team

Over the years, the Blue Jackets have had their share of talented players – especially over the last 7-8 years or so. The issue has been gathering enough of them at the same time to make this team a legitimate Stanley Cup contender.

Now that the team is seemingly building in that direction; I thought it might be fun to look at a few guys that have moved away, who might change the outlook of this team in a big way if they were still here. It goes without saying, this article is going to be contentious for a few reasons, but bear with me and my our reasoning for each pick.

It would be easy to go through and just pick out the best players, but that isn’t the point of the article. Sure, you would love to have an Artemi Panarin or Cam Atkinson back here; those are wildly exciting players that would draw crowds on their own. But who would get pushed out of the lineup if you brought one or both of those guys back? The point here is, these players would fit right into the lineup as it stands and help this team contend as constructed otherwise.

The best way to start this process is to assemble the roster we expect to see at training camp. We did that last week, with our own predictions and reasoning. Now, let’s play fantasy GM for a second, and be realistic … which players are playing out of their elements? This is how you have to look at the roster, if you want to turn this team into contention. For this exercise, we have removed the names of players that I feel aren’t in the right roles (here comes the first point of contention!):

Line 1: Gaudreau – ??? – Marchenko
Line 2: Johnson – ??? – Laine
Line 3: Texier – Fantilli – Chinakhov
Line 4: Robinson – Kuraly – Danforth
Extras: Voronkov, Olivier
Defense pair 1: Werenski – ???
Defense pair 2: Provorov – Severson
Defense pair 3: Bean – Gudbranson
Extra: Peeke
Goaltenders: Merzlikins, Tarasov

As you can see, it’s my opinion that this team is lacking two top-six centers, and a top pairing defenseman for the right side. It’s also my opinion that the goaltending is actually fine here; assuming both guys can stay healthy, the new structure of the team helps them prevent high danger shots, and the new goaltending coach has his stay.

I want to quickly point out that I’m not dropping any of Jenner, Boqvist, or Roslovic off of the roster – I’m just pointing out that I don’t see them as suitable in the roles they’re penciled into. Ideally, Jenner is on your third line, helping lead the way for some of the young guys in the lineup. Roslovic is better suited in a bottom-six role, and I’m still in wait-and-see mode with Boqvist.

If your goal is to contend now, these are the glaring needs you have. So, which former Jacket players who are still in the NHL might be able to fill those roles?

When I think back to the COVID year of hockey, it brings me a surprisingly fond memory. The Blue Jackets knocked the Toronto Maple Leafs out of the first round on the back of an emerging star center named Pierre-Luc Dubois.

I can’t tell you the exact words I used when he completed his hat trick in game three of that series, I’d like to keep this article G-rated. But, paraphrasing, I shouted loudly in my living room that “Luc was a MAN”. I wasn’t wrong; in that series he went up against the league’s most highly paid offense, helped shut them mostly down, and stole the show as the star of the series. I still get chills watching this highlight reel.

Unfortunately, as we all know, he quit on the team at the beginning of the next season. This prompted his trade to Winnipeg for Patrik Laine, a move that I don’t have any regrets about – Patty has been everything we wanted in a scoring winger since Artemi Panarin left, while Jack Roslovic has scored at a pretty similar pace to Dubois. But, it does make me wonder: what could have been with this team, had Dubois not pouted his way out of town?

Since the trade, he went on to score 143 points in 195 games for Winnipeg, before dropping his shoulders and forcing a trade again – this time to the LA Kings. He just signed an 8-year deal with an $8.5m AAV to play there, finally finding a place where it seems like he can be happy. He’s emerged as one of the premier physical/power two-way centers in the NHL; a guy who plays hard on both sides of the puck, and can play up and down the lineup as needed.

Had he stayed in Columbus and signed long-term, I think this rebuild would look a lot different than it does at this moment. We probably wouldn’t have some of the players/prospects we have, but for just a moment, imagine the other pieces here; and having PLD step onto a top line with Johnny Gaudreau and Kirill Marchenko. Look at what this does to the rest of the roster:

Line 1: Gaudreau – Dubois – Marchenko
Line 2: Johnson – Jenner – Laine
Line 3: Texier – Fantilli – Chinakhov
Line 4: Robinson – Kuraly – Danforth
Extras: Voronkov, Olivier
Defense pair 1: Werenski – Boqvist
Defense pair 2: Provorov – Severson
Defense pair 3: Bean – Gudbranson
Extra: Peeke
Goaltenders: Merzlikins, Tarasov

Adding Dubois to that top line would give the Jackets easily the best top-six forward group they’ve ever had. That top line would be a nightmare for opposition defenses; with Dubois and Marchenko both creating havoc on the forecheck, buying time for Gaudreau to make plays at will. By season’s end, you could be rolling him out with Fantilli on the second line, Jenner on the third, and Kuraly on the fourth. That’s a playoff caliber lineup for sure, and for that reason; whether you love him, hate him, or have just outright forgotten about him: Pierre-Luc Dubois would be perfect for this team.

So, you think the center position is going to be okay in due time. I do get it. This team surrendered 330 goals last year, and even though they added two quality veterans this summer, they still lack a high end player for the top pairing. You think they should fix that first. I don’t disagree. If only…

Like the Laine/Dubois situation, imagine this team with it’s prospect pool and depth now, but with Seth Jones on the roster. Right off the bat, the big caveat for me here would be his monster contract, which has him overpaid by probably $2-3m per year. With that aside though, he’s exactly what we need.

He’s a veteran of over 700 NHL games, and while his offense never translated into big numbers, we know very well what he’s capable of doing with and without the puck. He has the size, elite level skating, two-way presence, and transition game that meshes perfectly with Zach Werenski – we’ve witnessed it live. Imagine a top-four of Werenski, Jones, Ivan Provorov and Damon Severson … now you’re getting somewhere.

Like our other ideas, this changes the entire complexion of the team, and buys them plenty of time for David Jiricek and Corson Ceulemans to develop into future stalwarts on the right side. Probably most importantly, it means the team doesn’t divvy out $16 million on Erik Gudbranson last summer. With Seth on the roster though, this group is pretty darn good:

Line 1: Gaudreau – Jenner – Marchenko
Line 2: Johnson – Roslovic – Laine
Line 3: Texier – Fantilli – Chinakhov
Line 4: Robinson – Kuraly – Danforth
Extras: Voronkov, Olivier
Defense pair 1: Werenski – Jones
Defense pair 2: Provorov – Severson
Defense pair 3: Bean – Gudbranson
Extra: Peeke
Goaltenders: Merzlikins, Tarasov

There you have it – three former Jacket players that we feel could really help this team out of its current funk. With all of that said, it’s hard (nearly impossible) to pencil in a Dubois or Jones without gutting other major pieces of the lineup due to the salary cap. Even taking Gudbranson away, things get awful tight in a hurry – especially when you consider the young players that will need contracts soon.

In all, it’s just a dream anyhow. We could redo this whole thing and replace Dubois, Wennberg, and Jones with guys who weren’t former Blue Jackets but would be great fits here and have the same effect/outcome. But it’s fun to imagine what might have been, with these guys still around and the incoming pieces from the rebuild. Maybe in some other universe.