Skip to main content

It’s time for the Blue Jackets to commit to a full rebuild

In the 26-year history of the Columbus Blue Jackets, the team has never committed to a full rebuild. It’s finally time.
ByMatthew Duffey
Columbus Blue Jackets v Carolina Hurricanes
Columbus Blue Jackets v Carolina Hurricanes | Jared C. Tilton/GettyImages

The Blue Jackets entered the 2026-27 season with a lot of hope. Unfortunately, that hope has been short lived. The season has gone almost as poorly as it could go. The Blue Jackets sit dead last in the Eastern Conference and tied for second worst in the NHL. The team has the worst offense in the NHL and looks like it has no direction.

The Blue Jackets have been consistently a mediocre team in its 26-year history. Aside from a handful of playoff appearances and a single playoff series win, the team has taken full-time residence in the bottom third of the league standings.

While the team has been great at playing poor hockey, it’s almost never been the worst team in the league in a given season. The team is usually good enough to receive a top-10 pick in the draft. However, they haven’t been bad enough to merit a top 3 pick in the draft consistently. They have been stuck in no-man’s land through most of their tenure.

Given this, the team has never committed to a full rebuild. There have been multiple opportunities for a full rebuild, which the team never committed to:

The early years were filled with poor planning.

Many of the early seasons of the franchise, then GM Doug Maclean spent money on free agents and made trades to improve the club. His goal was to always make the playoffs. Yet, the team continually lacked the high-end talent and depth to compete at a high level. Poor drafting and player development led to consistent losing.

After the 2011-12 season, it looked like the team was going to do a full rebuild after trading disgruntled Jeff Carter and fan-favorite Rick Nash. However, then the unexpected 2013 season happened, where the team would on an incredible run to go from last place to just missing the playoffs. Management had hope of making the playoffs immediately after that season, which eliminated the rebuild plans at that time.

The late 2010s gave us hope, but it all fell apart.

After the 2018-19 season when players like Sergei Bobrovsky, Artemi Panarin, Matt Duchene, and others left, it looked like the team would be headed for a rebuild. But, as then GM Jarmo Kekalainan said, this is a retool not a rebuild. Thus, since that season, the team has been stuck in the mud and hasn’t qualified for a playoff berth.

There have been many opportunities for the team to do a full rebuild. Yet, time after time, the plans change and the team cannot develop into a true contender.

Now the question is: given the poor performance of this Blue Jackets team, what should management do? Well, much to the distaste of fans and ownership, it’s time to commit to a full rebuild.

Rebuilding from the ground up.

A full rebuild entails a ground-up roster overhaul. The club should elect to trade away veterans and roster players for future assets, such as prospects and draft picks. The goal is multiple years of landing high drafts picks and developing young talent that will eventually result in becoming a contender. Essentially, it is committing to multiple seasons of very poor hockey with the goal of long-term success.

The key here is better scouting/drafting to identify the best players to draft. Then developing those players into consistent, solid NHL players. Both are area’s the Blue Jackets have a poor track record in. That will need to improve for a full rebuild to be successful.

While it is not ideal for the 5th Line to endure a full rebuild, it may be the only way to turn this franchise around. Like seriously, what they have been doing for the last 26 years obviously hasn’t worked. Maybe this is the path that they should finally take.

Add us as a preferred source on Google