The Blue Jackets went onto Long Island last night needing to play their best brand of hockey in order to have a chance to beat the Islanders. That didn't happen. Or, if it did, it simply wasn't good enough. The Isles walked to an easy 5-1 win, led by their sophomore sensation on defense.
Consider what I said for just one second. We were worried that the Blue Jackets were going to have a hard night against the Islanders if they didn't bring something special. That team finished below the Jackets in the standings last year, and they're outside of the playoff bubble right now. That's how bad this CBJ team is right now.
After watching this team flounder for 60 minutes last night in an arena that wasn't even close to full, it's time to state the obvious: the Blue Jackets aren't good this year. In fact, they stink. They don't even look like they want to play out the string.
Slow start, worse finish.
The Jackets stumbled into this one and got shelled for the first several minutes of the game. The Islanders were swarming in the offensive zone, firing several high danger chances at Cam Talbot. But the veteran goaltender held his ground and gave his team a chance to get their legs going.
Eventually, they did just that, and started to show some pushback. Once they got their legs under them, I thought they played a pretty decent first period. Of course, you need to score to win hockey games, and that seems to be their Achilles heel right now.
The Islanders were able to get the game's first goal in the final minute of the period, with Anthony Duclair (remember him?) scoring on the power-play. We quipped on Twitter/X that this might be all it took last night, and we weren't entirely wrong.
Islanders make it 1-0, and that might be all they need against this Blue Jackets team. #CBJ
— Union and Blue (@UnionAndBlue) November 18, 2026
They would extend their lead to 2-0 just 1:34 into the second period, on a play that can be summed up with two words: Erik Gudbranson. After a cross-ice pass was broken up at the other end, it's a simple race to the puck.
A race that #44 in white isn't quick enough to win, but that shouldn't be the end of the world. It's a 2-on-2 rush, so all he has to do is take away time and space from the guy who wins the puck race. Run him into the wall, take away his angle and create a turnover. Or just pin the player/puck. He does not do any of those things.
Instead, he backs away from him, lets him dish it to a winger with speed, and gets burned down the wall. Then, when the Islanders actually mess this play up and shoot the puck right into his feet, he panics, hacks it into the high slot, right onto the stick of sophomore phenom Matthew Schaefer, who is waiting with time and space. Boom. 2-0.
I'm not sure who thought putting this guy back into the lineup was a good idea, but allow me to present exhibit A for why he should never see the ice again, unless they have absolutely no other option:
Watch #44 in white for this entire sequence.
— Union and Blue (@UnionAndBlue) November 18, 2026
I cannot believe anyone in a position of decision making sees this and goes "we need more of that in our lineup".
Absolutely ridiculous. #CBJ https://t.co/jTvvUO18mK
That goal, in reality, was all the Islanders needed. The Blue Jacket would get one back early in the third period, but they could not weather the momentum swing that somehow went the other way. The Isles simply took the game over and scored three more times, blowing out the Jackets and sending them on their way with a 5th straight loss.
They finished the night with the lowest scoring offense in the NHL, sitting tied for 30th-place. Of course, they lose on the tie breaker here, because they have just 2 regulation wins in their first 19 games. Really magical season so far, guys.
