Should the Jackets Make a Trade?

In short, no.  I don’t think the Jackets should make a move on any of the players coming up for trades in the next few days.  With the pre-Olympic trade deadline set for February 7, many teams are looking to move some players around.  The biggest names that have come up in hockey trade rumors recently are Ryan Callahan and Thomas Vanek. Personally, I don’t think either would be a good acquisition for the team right now, and here’s why.

Credit: Russell LaBounty-USA TODAY Sports

These two players are big-name players, and the Jackets have had no luck in acquiring big-time players in the past. First, there was Jeff Carter.  He was supposed to come to Columbus and make a difference, be a leader.  That flopped.  Not only did Carter not show up to perform, he made it known to the world that he didn’t want to be here.  This hurt morale on the bench, and lead to the team finishing last in the NHL and trading Carter to Los Angeles. I feel that bringing Vanek or Callahan to Columbus would likely end up in a similar, negative situation.

Additionally, there is Marian Gaborik.  The Jackets acquired Gaborik on the trade deadline last season, and he has been less than impressive this year.  Gaborik has been injured for the majority of this season, and it seems like the team plays better without him.  They won 8 games in a row with him out of the lineup.  It certainly seems as if the team plays better with Gaborik on the bench, and adding a player like him to the lineup just doesn’t make much sense.

Ryan Johansen represents the Jackets' identity as a young-gun team. Credit: Greg Bartram-USA TODAY Sports

Ryan Johansen represents the Jackets’ identity as a young-gun team. Credit: Greg Bartram-USA TODAY Sports

Lastly, the Jackets don’t need to bring in a big-name player to play well.  They have an identity as a young, hard-working team, and their play at the end of last season and through this past month certainly backs that up. Some fans have voiced the opinion that the return of Marian Gaborik will in fact hurt the Jackets, so there is no need to make a move to bring in a player similar to him. This team is playing well and competing for an Eastern Conference playoff spot, so there isn’t a desperate need to make changes. The Jackets are working on building a team, and making a trade for a player like Callahan or Vanek would, in my opinion, halt the forward progress of the franchise.  Now is not the time to make a change. What do you think?

Should the Jackets make a trade?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Topics: Columbus Blue Jackets

Want more from Union and Blue?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • Pingback: NHL Quick Shifts: California Dreamin', Olympic Threads, Fluky Isles

  • Mendel Andrusier

    I agree to not acquiring a big name. I do think the jackets should look at some veteran names with playoff experience since there isnt a ton of that on this team.

    • Julia Lawrence

      I agree. I think playoff experience was a big reason they signed Horton, but there isn’t much of it on the team since they are so young. I wouldn’t object to getting some veterans, as long as it didn’t hurt the team like Carter did.

  • RedStorm45

    Yes, trade Blol.

  • RedStorm45

    You’re indirectly making a case that Gaborik should be traded, then say no the CBJ shouldn’t make a trade. Wat.

    Wiz was a fairly big name free agent. Horton was a big name free agent signing. Jack Johnson was/is a big name player. Gaborik played pretty well down the stretch last year.